What are the Red Flags for PPP Loan Fraud?
and has been seen on Forbes, CNBC and Fox Business.
Speak with Dr. Oberheiden today for a free consultation at 888-680-1745.
Federal authorities are targeting individuals and companies suspected of defrauding the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP). Are you at risk? Here are some red flags that could trigger an investigation.
The federal Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) is subject to a bevy of rules and restrictions. Acknowledging PPP loan applicants’ compliance burdens (and the limited information that was initially made available to applicants), the U.S. Small Business Administration (SBA) offered a grace period within which companies could return improperly obtained PPP loans without penalty. However, this grace period has expired, and now the SBA Office of Inspector General (SBA-OIG), the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ), and other federal agencies are aggressively targeting companies suspected of engaging in PPP loan fraud.
If your company received a PPP loan, is it at risk? Are you personally at risk as a company owner, executive, or board member? These are important questions, and they are questions that you need to answer sooner rather than later. When the SBA-OIG or DOJ launches an investigation, executing a timely and effective defense is critical. To this end, all companies that received PPP loans would be well-advised to proactively conduct an internal PPP compliance investigation. At Oberheiden P.C., we are actively representing companies with regard to PPP compliance during the COVID-19 pandemic, and we are representing companies in PPP loan fraud audits and investigations as well.
10 Red Flags for PPP Loan Fraud (Look for These During Your Company’s Internal PPP Compliance Investigation)
Despite the fact that the Paycheck Protection Program was just launched in March 2020 with the enactment of the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act, federal authorities have already identified several hallmarks of PPP loan fraud. As a result, they are looking for a number of specific red flags during audits and investigations, and companies must look for these same red flags when conducting their internal PPP compliance investigations as well.
Here are 10 red flags for PPP loan fraud:
1. No Documentation to Substantiate Representations in the Company’s PPP Loan Application
During the PPP loan application process, companies are required to make a number of affirmative representations. For example, under the terms of the program, companies must represent that:
- They have fewer than 500 employees, qualify as a “small business concern” under Section 3 of the Small Business Act, or meet one of the limited number of other PPP eligibility standards;
- They are applying for a PPP loan because, “the uncertainty of current economic conditions makes necessary the loan request to support the ongoing operations of the eligible recipient;” and,
- Their owners are eligible to participate in SBA programs such as the PPP (i.e. no owner of a 20% or greater interest has been convicted of or pleaded guilty to a federal felony within the past five years).
During a federal PPP loan fraud audit or investigation, federal agents will not only be seeking to assess loan recipients’ eligibility, but they will also be seeking to determine whether companies have documentation on hand to substantiate the representations they made in their PPP loan applications.
2. Multiple PPP Loan Applications Submitted to Different Lenders
Under the CARES Act, companies are only eligible to receive one PPP loan from one lender at a time. Obtaining multiple PPP loans (or “stacking” PPP loans) is prohibited, and companies that applied with multiple lenders could face allegations for attempting to stack PPP loans. Even if only one PPP loan was obtained, attempting to obtain multiple loans can still lead to criminal prosecution. Under 18 U.S.C. § 1349, individuals and companies charged with attempt can face the same penalties that apply to the “successful” completion of a criminal offense (i.e. bank fraud, making false statements to an FDIC-insured financial institution, or making false statements to the SBA).
3. No Adoption of PPP Compliance Policies and Procedures
In addition to its application requirements, the CARES Act also establishes requirements for how companies use, and account for the use of, PPP loan funds. As a result, upon receiving PPP loans (or, ideally, in anticipation of receiving a PPP loan), companies should adopt policies and procedures designed to ensure ongoing PPP compliance. If a company does not have documented policies and procedures for PPP compliance, this is going to be viewed as a red flag for fraud in the event of an SBA audit or an SBA-OIG or DOJ investigation.
4. No Establishment of a Separate PPP Loan Account
A key aspect of the PPP is that companies are only permitted to use the funds they receive for specific authorized purposes. These purposes include the payment of payroll and related expenses, the payment of rent and mortgage interest under pre-existing obligations, the payment of insurance premiums, and the payment of business utility bills. In order to account for all disbursements from their PPP loans, companies should deposit their loans into segregated accounts, and they should not commingle their PPP loan funds with any other company assets.
5. No Documentation (or Inadequate or Incomplete Documentation) of PPP Loan Expenditures
When making use of PPP loan funds, companies should thoroughly document their expenditures in order to demonstrate that they have used their PPP loans for authorized purposes only. In many instances, this will require more than simply recording the transaction itself. Similar to compliance program documentation, inadequate documentation of PPP loan expenditures will be viewed as a red flag for fraud, and it can place companies in a difficult position when it comes to defending against federal fraud allegations.
6. Use of PPP Loan Funds for Personal Expenses
Using PPP loan funds for personal expenses is expressly prohibited under the terms of the PPP. The DOJ has already initiated multiple federal cases against individuals alleged to have converted PPP loan funds for personal use, and in these cases the defendants are facing substantial fines and years, if not decades, of federal imprisonment. While egregious and obvious misuse of PPP loan funds presents a clear risk, expenditures that blend business and personal purposes (i.e. payments for travel, vehicles, and home office expenses) can create risk as well.
7. Inadequate or Questionable Documentation Submitted in Support of Loan Forgiveness Certification
Another key aspect of the PPP is that loans issued under the program are eligible to be forgiven if they are used entirely for authorized purposes. When seeking forgiveness, companies must provide documentation, and they must affirmatively certify as to the accuracy of this documentation and as to compliance itself. Inadequate or questionable documentation submitted in support of a request for PPP loan forgiveness is another major red flag, and companies accused of submitting fraudulent forgiveness requests can face a variety of federal charges.’
8. Newly-Formed Business Entities, New Debt Obligations, and Other Atypical Business Activities
Additional red flags for PPP loan fraud include atypical business activities such as forming new business entities and entering into new debt obligations. Federal auditors and investigators will view these types of activities skeptically, and as potential evidence of an attempt to either fraudulently obtain a PPP loan or use PPP loan funds for unauthorized purposes. Again, thorough documentation is critical, and companies must ensure that all relevant internal personnel are aware of the types of activities that can increase the company’s risk of liability in the event of a PPP loan fraud audit or investigation.
9. Evasiveness or Inability (or Unwillingness) to Produce Documentation of PPP Compliance
Evasiveness and inability (or unwillingness) to produce documentation of PPP compliance is a red flag for fraud as well. For companies, this includes evasiveness from employees during internal PPP compliance investigations; and, for federal authorities such as the SBA-OIG and the DOJ, it includes suspect activity from any and all company personnel who are involved in responding to the government’s inquiry. This is based on the adage that where there is smoke, there is fire. If someone seems concerned about what might be found, there is usually a reason why.
10. Other Issues Pertaining to Substantiation, Documentation, and Compliance
Finally, in addition to all of the red flags for PPP loan fraud discussed above, there are numerous other issues that can tip off federal authorities during audits and investigations as well. In order to ensure that no one at your company raises questions for federal authorities unnecessarily, it is essential to rely on the advice and representation of experienced federal counsel.
‘At Oberheiden P.C., our attorneys and former federal agents are intimately familiar with the federal auditing and investigative processes. We can use our experience to help mitigate your company’s risk (and your personal risk) to the fullest extent possible, and we encourage you to contact us for a free and confidential assessment of your company’s legal needs.
Oberheiden P.C. | Compliance and Defense Counsel for PPP Loan Recipients Nationwide
Is your company (or are you personally) at risk for facing allegations of PPP loan fraud? To speak with one of our senior federal compliance and defense attorneys in confidence, call 888-680-1745 or request a free PPP risk assessment online now.